It was my unfortunate responsibility to tell Susan (not her real name) that her pregnancy test was positive. She was a senior at a local high school and the head cheerleader. She was an honor student headed for college and planning to become a pediatrician. Now she was weeping silently in my office. I began to encourage her as best I could as her mother sat stone faced watching the two of us. Knowing that she came from a church going family, I began to encourage her by saying that God would give her grace to be a good mother and to handle the difficulties that she would face. As I was saying that although this unplanned pregnancy would definitely change the direction of her life it would not ruin her life, her mother suddenly threw up her hand and said to me, “Stop. She is not going to have this baby. You are going to refer us to the abortion clinic.”
As you can imagine, I was stunned. I knew that this mother and her husband were churchgoing people. I knew that her husband was a deacon and Sunday school teacher. I quietly began to point out that such an action would be a violation of their Christian convictions, whereupon, Susan’s mother stood up and quickly left the room. Susan began to sob uncontrollably. I comforted her as best I could and then said, “You need to go home with your mother, but I think you need to talk to your father about this.”
What just happened in that exam room? What happened was a sacrifice of personal convictions. This Christian woman allowed difficult circumstances to dictate her theology rather than allowing her theology to dictate her response to difficult circumstances. Her Christian belief became hostage to a difficult life situation. Her Christian convictions were sacrificed on the altar of personal convenience. It simply was not convenient for her teenage daughter to be pregnant at that time. We call this situational ethics or moral relativism. Suddenly, this mom’s sense of moral right and wrong was no longer set in stone (like the ten commandments which say “thou shalt not kill”) but was a relative thing subject to the whim of circumstances. Please, don’t misunderstand me. I am not minimizing the emotional difficulty of this particular situation. However, no matter how desperate the circumstances surrounding an unplanned pregnancy, nothing justifies the killing of an innocent, unborn child. We Christians say that our decisions are informed by the scriptures. If so, then we need to be consistent and not full of double standards. If we say that the life of the unborn is sacred, created in the image of God, then we should behave that way even in the difficult circumstances. We should allow our theological convictions to determine our response to difficult social dilemmas even when our teenage daughter or granddaughter is involved with an unplanned pregnancy.
Seventeen years later, Susan came back in to my office with her pretty blue eyes and her blonde hair. She brought with her a 6-foot 2 inch tall 17-year-old son for a football physical. He was all knees and elbows with a big lantern jaw and I could already tell he was going to be one of those men who would need to shave twice a day. After I completed his exam, she came back into the room and sat in the exact same chair where her mother has sat 17 years prior. She looked at me and said, “Dr. Jackson do you remember…”. Our eyes connected and we both remembered the titanic spiritual battle that occurred in that very exam room 17 years before for the life of her unborn son. Tears formed in our eyes and then we both began to weep for a moment. I just nodded and said, “Yes ma’am, I remember. I’ll always remember.”
Later, I wondered what that 17-year-old boy thought was going on between his momma and that red neck country doctor!